REQUEST A TOUR If you would like to see this home without being there in person, select the "Virtual Tour" option and your agent will contact you to discuss available opportunities.
In-PersonVirtual Tour
$ 6,000,000
Est. payment | /mo
5,400 SqFt
$ 6,000,000
Est. payment | /mo
5,400 SqFt
Key Details
Property Type Commercial
Sub Type Commercial/Industrial
Listing Status Active
Purchase Type For Sale
Square Footage 5,400 sqft
Price per Sqft $1,111
MLS Listing ID 262303
Annual Tax Amount $28,362
Tax Year 2025
Lot Dimensions 4200
Property Sub-Type Commercial/Industrial
Property Description
504 & 506 Washington Street / 510 Carpenter's Lane — Cape May, NJ Three addresses. Five income streams. One contiguous parcel with frontage on both the Washington Street Mall and Carpenter's Lane. 504 Washington Street — A 20-by-80-foot storefront, approximately 1,600 square feet of deep, well-proportioned retail on the mall's most heavily trafficked block. Currently leased through December 2028 at $68,600. Second floor, 504 — Above the retail floor, the upper level provides office and support space, currently occupied by the ground-floor tenant on a short-term basis. Above-grade area on the Washington Street Mall is genuinely scarce, and this level offers an incoming owner immediate flexibility: continue as tenant support space, lease it independently as office, or reconfigure it toward its highest use. Residential apartment — A separate residential unit within the building, held on a short-term basis. Independent of the commercial tenancies and independent of their rollover schedule, it gives the parcel a fourth use type and a distinct income character. 506 Washington Street — An identical 20-by-80 footprint alongside 504, leased through December 2029 at $100,000. Together the two storefronts give an owner 40 feet of continuous mall frontage — a width that's difficult to assemble on a corridor where buildings changed hands generations ago. 510 Carpenter's Lane — A compact 30-by-25.5-foot space at the rear of the parcel, operating as a bakery under a lease through January 2029 with a mutual renewal option. Its own address, its own frontage, and access from a second street. The combined position. Five tenancies producing $255,600 annually against $27,428 in taxes, staggered across 2028 and 2029 rather than expiring together — an owner can reposition one unit at a time while the balance of the parcel keeps producing. Two of the five are short-term, offering immediate control. Worth investigating: condominium conversion. Three addresses, dual street frontage, and four distinct use types on a single parcel raise a real question about whether the block is better held whole or subdivided. Subject to municipal approval and historic district review, a condominium structure could allow units to be sold or financed individually — a path that doesn't exist for most buildings on the mall. Two mall storefronts, a Carpenter's Lane bakery, second-floor office, and a residential apartment. Assembled parcels like this one don't come apart often, and they don't come back together at all. Leases available upon request. This parcel is one of seven properties in the seller's portfolio, spanning Cape May, Ocean City, Wildwood, and Stone Harbor. Whole-portfolio pricing available upon request. Offered individually at $6,000,000.
Location
State NJ
Area Cape May
Zoning c-1
Interior
Heating Gas Natural
Cooling Central Air Conditioning
Building
Sewer City
Water City
Listed by HOFFMAN AGENCY
"My job is to find and attract mastery-based agents to the office, protect the culture, and make sure everyone is happy! "